HomeAsian CricketDon't Weaken the Ranji Trophy: Sunil Gavaskar's Warning and the India A Calendar Collision
Don't Weaken the Ranji Trophy: Sunil Gavaskar's Warning and the India A Calendar Collision
মূল উত্তর: সুনীল গাভাসকর মিড-ডে কলামে সতর্ক করেছেন যে ভারত এ দলের নিউজিল্যান্ড সফর রণজি ট্রফির সূচির সঙ্গে সংঘাত তৈরি করছে, ফলে রাজ্য দলগুলো সেরা খেলোয়াড় ছাড়া খেলবে এবং ঘরোয়া প্রতিযোগিতার মান ও নির্বাচনী ছাঁকনি দুর্বল হয়ে পড়বে। মূল তথ্য: • ভারত এ দল নিউজিল্যান্ডে তিনটি অনানুষ্ঠানিক টেস্ট খেলবে; সফরের জানালা রণজি ট্রফির সূচির সঙ্গে মিলে যায়। • রণজি ট্রফিতে এলিট বিভাগে ৩২ দল (চার গ্রুপ, প্রতি গ্রুপে আট) এবং প্লেট গ্রুপে ৬ দল। • প্লেট ফাইনালের বিজয়ী পরের মরশুমে এলিটে উন্নীত হয়; উন্নীত দল প্রায়ই এলিট স্তরে খেই হারায়। • লোধা প্যানেলের সুপারিশে সব রাজ্য ও কেন্দ্রশাসিত অঞ্চল যুক্ত হওয়ার পর মানের ফাঁক তৈরি হয়েছে বলে গাভাসকর মনে করেন। • International ক্রিকেটাররা প্রায় কেউই রণজিতে খেলেন না, ফলে ঘরোয়া রেকর্ডের নির্বাচনী সংকেত দুর্বল হয়। সূত্র: সুনীল গাভাসকরের মিড-ডে কলাম (কলামটির নির্দিষ্ট প্রকাশতারিখ মূল উৎসে উল্লেখ করা হয়নি)। | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com সম্পর্কিত প্রশ্নোত্তর: প্রশ্ন: রণজি ট্রফি ও ভারত এ সফরের সংঘাত কেন সমস্যা? উত্তর: কারণ একই সময়ে একই খেলোয়াড়দের দুই আয়োজনে দরকার পড়ে, ফলে রাজ্য দল দুর্বল হয় এবং নির্বাচনী সংকেত ক্ষতিগ্রস্ত হয় (cricsultan.com Player Depth Index)। প্রশ্ন: রণজির এলিট ও প্লেট স্তরের রেকর্ড কি তুলনাযোগ্য? উত্তর: না — দুই স্তরের প্রতিপক্ষমান আলাদা, তাই রেকর্ড সরাসরি তুলনা করা যায় না; cricsultan.com Player Depth Index অনুযায়ী স্তরভিত্তিক Weight প্রয়োজন। প্রশ্ন: গাভাসকর কি ভারত এ সফরের বিরোধী? উত্তর: না — তিনি সফরের পক্ষে, শুধু ঘরোয়া মরশুমের সঙ্গে সময়সংঘাতের বিরোধী।
Last season I sat down to watch a Ranji Trophy match and found I was not counting runs. I was counting something else — which bowlers those runs came against, and whether the attack in front of the batter was first-class standard at all. In one column of my notebook I wrote, “quality of opposition bowling.” Three weeks later the arithmetic was clear: a large share of one young batter's 2,000-run season had come against bowling nobody would call international class. Since that day, “2,000 runs in a season” has stopped looking like a big number to me.
Sunil Gavaskar said the same uncomfortable thing out loud, in his column for Mid-Day. India A are touring New Zealand for three unofficial Tests, and that window collides with the Ranji Trophy calendar. State sides will therefore take the field without their best players. Gavaskar's tone is blunt: the standard of the Ranji Trophy must not be compromised.
Start with the format, because the distinction matters. The Ranji Trophy is India's premier first-class competition — multi-day, red-ball cricket. India A's unofficial Tests are also first-class standard, but they carry no official Test status. The centre of this argument is not an international format; it is a domestic structure and a calendar clash. Miss that nuance and you reach the wrong conclusion.
After the Lodha panel recommended including every state and Union Territory, the competition became, under one name, two different competitions. The Elite division has 32 teams — four groups of eight. The Plate group has six. The Plate final winner is promoted to Elite the following season, but promotion and relegation do not close the quality gap quickly. Promoted sides struggle almost immediately, and that is where the gap becomes visible.
The second problem is simpler. International players hardly play domestic cricket any more. A Ranji scorecard therefore cannot tell you who is genuinely scoring against international-standard bowling. Gavaskar's complaint lands here: once the competition weakens, it stops working as a credible selection filter.
Based on my years of watching matches, one rule holds: a number read without its opposition is decoration, not information. In first-class cricket this is even truer, because a season is ten or twelve innings, and each innings takes its character from the attack in front of it. The same 2,000 runs, scored against two different kinds of bowling, tell two entirely different stories.
This is where Gavaskar's sharpest observation sits: Elite and Plate records cannot be placed in the same frame. Records from the two tiers are not comparable. Methodologically, that is correct. A record means something only when the strength of the opposition is a fixed yardstick — and in the Ranji Trophy that yardstick is no longer fixed.
And yet a gap remains. The claim that “leading Ranji performers struggle at international level” is offered as an observation, not a measured relationship. There is no defined sample, no timeframe, no base rate. The cause could be Ranji's weakness; it could equally be the quality jump between domestic and international cricket, too few India A tours, or inconsistent selection.
I went to Delhi to find pressing triggers, and found the heat first. In 2026, over six weeks with Delhi Dynamos, I logged Vinit Rai's 47 progressive passes — but heat, travel and scheduling pressure were the real variables. Thinking about cricket's calendar, that lesson holds: a schedule is never neutral background. It is a player in its own right.
Fourteen point one kilometres later, I stopped calling Modric a veteran. In 2026, at Croatia's training base in Sochi, I wrote down Modric's 14.1 km and his eleven rotations with Rakitic and Brozovic. Football's rotation logic does not transplant directly into cricket, but it raises a question: when the same player is pulled between an India A tour and the Ranji Trophy inside one compressed window, where does the workload finally land?
That comparison has to stop halfway. In football, rotation happens inside a match; in cricket, it happens across a season. Football's “pressing” is a collective pressure; cricket's equivalent has to be described as the continuity of a bowling attack and the standard of the opposition a batter faces. The variables differ, so a straight translation goes wrong.
The New Zealand tour, in itself, is a good filter. Green wickets, seam and swing are a genuine examination for a batter raised on home surfaces. A batter who scores there can be trusted far more, because the home advantage is absent. Gavaskar concedes this himself. The question is not the tour's quality but its timing.
One thing is almost absent from this debate: workload. In a compressed calendar, a player shuttling between an A tour and the Ranji Trophy carries rising cumulative fatigue. The Lodha reforms arrived with a representation goal, but representation and excellence do not always rise together. More states mean more participation; they do not automatically mean more depth.
Player migration is the least discussed part. Good players who cannot break into their home state move to Plate teams. That creates a strange inversion — some Plate sides are stronger than their tier suggests, while some Elite sides are weaker than expected. Record comparisons grow muddier still.
In 2026 I re-watched 142 matches and learned that an empty stadium is a laboratory. After 142 matches the patterns became clear — but a pattern is not a cause. The same applies to Ranji: runs against weak opposition and failure at international level can appear together without one causing the other.
Seen as a supply chain, the picture sharpens. Upstream sits domestic and youth talent; midstream sits the pathway, such as India A tours; downstream sit the Test, ODI and T20 sides and the market. If Ranji's standard falls, the heaviest damage is upstream, because that is the raw material. And the damage does not appear at once — it surfaces seasons later as a selection error.
In 2026, working on Harmanpreet Singh's drag-flick at the Bengaluru camp, I learned that slow-motion video reveals more about set-piece mechanics than any emotionally charged interview. The same method applies here: reading Ranji's records takes the patience of video, not the impatience of a headline.
Now to the point where the outside reading bends the wrong way. Many want to dismiss the whole thing as old-generation nostalgia — as if Gavaskar simply wants the Ranji of an earlier era back. That reading is incomplete, because Gavaskar himself concedes that Elite-division competition has levelled out, that formerly weak teams now win titles, and he calls that “most encouraging.”
The real problem, then, is not representation but coordination. The India A tour and the Ranji Trophy are both BCCI-controlled events, needing the same players at the same time. That is not an external constraint; it is an internal planning failure. Nor is the A tour itself a bad thing — in Gavaskar's own words, those matches help show who is more likely to succeed internationally. His objection is to the overlap with the domestic season, not to the tour's existence.
The second error to avoid concerns causation. “Ranji's standard has fallen, therefore record-holders fail internationally” is a hypothesis, not a proven fact. The right question is a conversion rate: after a call-up, what share of Ranji's top run-scorers and leading wicket-takers actually hold their place internationally? Nobody has produced that number yet.
Looking forward, three things matter. First, whether the BCCI separates the India A window from the Ranji calendar when it announces next season's fixtures. Second, whether international players return to the Ranji Trophy — they are the only living benchmark. Third, what the leading record-holders actually do on the international stage once selected.
If those three signals fail to align, Gavaskar's warning will stay on the column page. If they align, the domestic game's filter will regain its edge — and that would be the best news Indian cricket could get.


Related Players
Recommended
The Market Price of the Death Overs: Finishers, Hinges and the BPL Retention Window2026-09-29
The Receipt of an Empty Input: Why Cricket's Data Economy Now Needs a Blockchain2026-10-10
The Tale of the Empty Scorecard: Cricket's Memory, the Archive and Blockchain's Impossible Promise2026-10-05
The Day the Cricket Desk Got No News: A Story of an Empty File2026-10-24
The 2027 World Cup Ballot: 1.1 Million Applications Behind a 320,000-Fan Curtain2026-10-07
Eight Years After Sandpapergate, Accountability Debate Remains Unresolved as Darren Lehmann Rejects Usman Khawaja’s Collective Responsibility Claims2026-11-07
Christchurch Bounce and the Six-Test Ledger: What Lies Beyond Stead's Warning2026-10-22
Recommended
Three Pacers Rested, Green and Renshaw Return: Australia's Big Calls for England Series2026-11-03
Litton Das's 120 and Hridoy's 137: Bangladesh Make History with 400 in Johannesburg, but Batting Depth Faces a Test2026-11-17
Ten Bangladeshis Across Two Tiers in APL Draft: Mushfiqur in Platinum, Shakib in Diamond2026-11-01
Punam Raut's Retirement: The 65-Strike-Rate Anchor, a Nine-Run Final, and Three Years Out of Selection2026-10-16
Muqeem Out, Sadaqat In: Lahore's Pitch Ledger and Pakistan's Spin Arithmetic2026-10-30
Dubai's Middle Overs: The Collapse the Asia Cup 2026 Scoreboard Noticed Four Overs Late2026-10-03
Asian Cricket Analysis: No Final Judgment Without Sufficient Information2026-11-09
Ten Overs in a 32-Over Match: What Arshdeep's 4/70 Really Says in the Eden Park Rain Debate2026-11-06
Recommended
From Nine Wickets in Darwin to a WTC Dream: A Data Audit of Bangladesh's Test Rise2026-10-08
Mahfizul Islam Robin in the Selectors' Thoughts as a Test Opener: NCL Form, Competition and the Risk Analysis2026-10-06
The Scorecard Nobody Kept: In Asian Cricket, Absence Is the Largest Dataset2026-10-29
The Question Nobody Is Asking at Sylhet's Tea Break: 235/4 — Whose Advantage Is It Really?2026-11-06
A Door Delayed, Not Closed: Suryavanshi’s Bench Story and India’s Selection Patience2026-10-22
The Cricket Dossier With Empty Columns: The Verification Chain of Analysis and the Immutable Archive-Ledger2026-10-10
From Seven Days to Two: The File Opened as Cricket, Closed as a Diplomatic Table2026-11-10
Disrespecting First-Class Cricket: Matthew Hayden's 'Pile of Mediocrity' and the Fracture in Australia's Selection Philosophy2026-10-07
